Saturday, April 10, 2010

Thoughts on Sustainable Change

The leadership in a distinguished organization seeks to advance a large-scale change initiative. Among the foods for thought presented is John Kotter’s “The Eight Step Process for Successful Change.” The first step: “Create a sense of urgency. Help others see the need for change and the importance of acting immediately.”

For a couple of years I co-led the Step III workshop of the Planning Institute of the Society for College and University Planning, and Kotter’s book Leading Change was part of our framework. We occasionally debated the nature of the sense of urgency – does it stem from threats or from aspirations? My own reading of Kotter was that he saw a need to represent a negative force and stimulate our survival instincts.

My path subsequently wound through Peter Senge’s Fifth Discipline and the Society for Organizational Learning. Systems thinking would show that using a negative urgency to stimulate change will make that change unsustainable. If the idea is to engender preferred behavior to eliminate a threat – perceived or otherwise - the lifespan of that behavior is in doubt once the threat is eliminated. The best examples are in colleges and universities. There the preferred stimulus for change is a deficit-orientation, generally arising from assessment. In spite of growing attention to the process, things remain as described by a friend in the Center for Creative Leadership: “It’s easier to move a cemetery than to change a university.”

In the Step III workshop we also used Malcolm Gladwell’s Blink. One of the stories we did not discuss was a tragic example of how our focus narrows in the face of a threat. It can be argued that if the change needed is adaptive as opposed to merely technical – changing the way we think as opposed to just changing what we do – it is imperative that we widen our focus. According to Barbara Fredrickson’s work our focus widens and narrows as the positivity of our situation varies. A widening of focus is not only critical to our receptiveness toward new ideas, but it also drives an essential component of long term success: our creativity.

So, in what ways might a positive sense of urgency arise? It can begin with a question as simple as “What do we want more of?” It’s a simple phrase that holds the past, the present and the future together interactively, and it sets up a series of dialogues that engage the entire system. Once the usual conversations begin to change, the leadership can breathe normally in the confidence that things are on their way.

Monday, March 1, 2010

Thinking Through Positivity

I’m fully invested now in Appreciative Inquiry and the broader spectrum of strengths-based and positive approaches. Still, sometimes it’s a challenge for me to explain the rationale to others without that song coming up way in the back of my mind: Keep on the sunny side, always on the….. There’s far more to it than that. I’m also beginning to think that the power of a positive orientation is not as much of a secret as it sometimes seems.

The fundamental example for me is the artist. Michelangelo was not problem-solving when he made the Pieta; there was a lot more going on. When Picasso painted Les Desmoiselles d’Avignon, I doubt that it was because an accreditation agency identified a deficit of Cubism in the art world.

I see other signs. Recently a finance manager noted that if a company has numerous business units, and some are making money and others are losing money, you should not immediately invest in the weak ones. Invest in the strong ones and raise the worth of the whole much faster. In a recent New York Times article Dr. Tachi Yamada talked about the value in finding the positive attributes in analyses and people, and spending your time on those as opposed to just the shortfalls. In the book Born to Run, they point out that species evolve according to what they’re good at. In Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation Kees Van Der Heijden points out that tomorrow’s core competencies come from today’s.


Sometimes when I feel like flying really low, I’ll claim that “No organization ever advanced itself by focusing on its deficiencies.” I have not a shred of evidence for such bombast, but I really do believe it. At the same time, one mustn’t paint with too wide a brush. As pointed out in Metaphors in Mind there are times when it’s appropriate to pull a few weeds.


I also believe that a positive approach ultimately entails really hard work. It’s really easy to call out what we don’t want, but have you ever found it hard to say what you do want? It can be a little tougher. And when we find our strengths, our abilities when at our best, that knowledge brings with it an obligation to always strive for that level. It’s not work for weenies, but our future depends on it.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

S.O.A.R. Meets Visual Explorer

I recently worked with an information technology services group in thinking through the changes emerging in their work. The design approach was framed around Appreciative Inquiry and S.O.A.R. The "A" is for Aspirations, and to work with that we used Visual Explorer.

The group had worked through an extensive Discovery phase over the summer, and prior to this session a few came together and synthesized their findings into Strengths and Opportunities. Working from those, we then articulated the group's Purpose. They were then asked to think for a few minutes and create a mental image about what life would be like if they were fluidly deploying those Strengths and Opportunities and serving that Purpose.

Around the room we had scattered the Visual Explorer cards, and we invited everyone to select one that best represented their mental image. They then worked in pairs to share their selections and thoughts, and subsequently the whole group worked with a cardstorming process to describe its shared aspirations.

Five Aspirations emerged. Once they were on the wall, they were asked if one of their selected Visual Explorer cards seemed to describe each one; some merited more than one image. They were then asked if there was a single image that seemed to represent the collection of aspirations, and they chose two: a picture of puzzle pieces as a description of where they are now, and a photo of Stonehenge to represent the firmness and completeness of their future.

Quick'n'Dirty PowerPoint

Have you ever had a mildly complicated point that you wanted to get across to just a few people? Have you ever felt trapped and confined when someone turned on a projector? I recently confronted these puzzles and explored a low-tech approach: index cards. The logic I was presenting had 9 or so steps, so I wrote each in very simple phrasing on a folded index card. It took about a minute and a half to talk through them, standing each on the table as though dealing from a deck. At that point they were a lot more useful than a slide show because they were all on the table together, instead of one at a time. As the conversation continued we could refer to them, move them around and otherwise work from a complete picture.

I'm thinking a next step might be to find do-it-yourself business cards that are made with a fold, and try using more refined text and images.

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

A World Cafe for Entering Medical Students

Last week our newest class of first-year medical students arrived for week of orientation. One of the expectations placed on them is that they will make an early and formal commitment to a set of professional behaviors that they will honor throughout their education and then on into their professional lives.

The Senior Associate Dean for Academic Affairs asked if I would help her work with the group - 80 in all - to fashion an agreement. I suggested that we might not do justice to some
thing that deep with so many in so little time - they had allotted two hours - and that we would do well to instead hold an exploratory conversation that would produce the content around which a written agreement could be drafted afterward. In that light a Cafe Conversation seemed perfect.

The session began with a presentation on the essential professional behaviors expected of physicians. These were described as Aspirations of Professionalism and I used those as a starting point on the graphic record drawing them in ahead of time.

Using a tent card, each table was designated as the site for one of the six aspirations. The students were instructed to then rotate each time to a different aspiration as well as to a different group of people. They were asked to reflect on this question with each aspiration: What commitments are we willing to make to our professional development and professional competence?

As I strolled the room during the table rounds, I began to be concerned as a couple of the sixteen tables were a little less engaged than the others. I didn't know quite how to read it, as this was only the second cafe I'd held with so many people. In many ways this particular week is a grueling boot camp for these young men and women, so I wondered if they were just running out of gas. Of course, I also had to second-guess the design.

The Harvesting, however, eliminated all doubts as the Cafe Magic kicked in. The reflections were slow to come at first, but as the outflow steadied it also grew deeper. By the time we were done the attendees not only expressed their satisfaction (and I love applause) but also took it upon themselves to designate a small group to craft the agreement that they will subsequently sign.

The graphic record moved the next morning into one of the classrooms they would be using during the day. Parents were on campus to see the "white coat ceremony" at days end, and I had the pleasure of seeing some of the students bring their family in to see the chart. the image will be included in their written agreement, and then kept around in poster form for the duration of this class's time here.

Friday, July 3, 2009

Mindmapping The Whuffie Factor

I recently read Tara Hunt's The Whuffie Factor, and it reminded me of one of the cards from Leadership Metaphor Explorer. From there I signed on for a trial copy of Buzan's iMindMap and gave it a whirl.Most of the mapping I've done so far has been with Mindjet. It's really powerful software but I'm thinking it just doesn't exert the same kind of energy as a more organic and free flowing form.

Sunday, June 28, 2009

Toward a Diagnostic for Process Design

We've all been there: a carefully orchestrated change process is suddenly steered into another direction in the interest of "more action and less talk." Having embarked on an engagement designed to use Appreciative Inquiry and completing a first Discovery session, the decision was made that there would be no topical interviews and a revised schedule had no Dream phase. What happened?

Two things come to mind for future improvement: being more circumspect about taking "yes" for an answer, and becoming much more rigorous about jointly developing an agreed-upon change agenda. In this particular incident, AI was warmly viewed as an excellent tool for the issues at hand; however, it's possible that the AI solution was on the table before the task was fully analyzed. For instance, my assumption was that the change agenda had been previously determined as bringing Change, Progress and Renewal to the issue at hand. It was much later that I finally realized the intended message: the issue needs CPR. This is not the positive orientation upon which AI builds its success, and it seems to be a contributor to how things ran off the track.

The revised approach for this project will move more immediately into specific content and analysis; again, a pressure that many clients face for varying reasons. The choice that has to be made is around the value of a "deeper dive" that creates the capacity for fundamental change. For instance, we know that if new thinking doesn't permeate our conversations, our images don't change and therefore neither will our practices. We know from the Anticipatory Principle that there is huge potential in moving toward what we value as opposed to away from what we dislike. It can also be shown that the creation of images of ideal outcomes reveals alignment in group thinking; recent brain research shows higher levels of creativity in such positive atmospheres as opposed to the usual orientation of problem elimination.

A pattern that appears in a large body of work is that of a distinct "turn" in collective thinking under certain circumstances. Thomas Kuhn described it as the result of sufficient dissonance; Arthur M. Young showed it as a 90-degree turn, such that the new direction is equally different from its original destination and its source; Drexler and Sibbet described it as a point of commitment, Scharmer as the opening of will, Block as the point at which "the answer to How? is Yes!" Mapping these will often show a "u" or "v" shape, with various levels along the vertical dimension, and to these levels can be added those of the iceberg used in systems thinking.

The horizontal dimension can be described as moving from intention to action, as shown in the Enneagram work by G.I. Gurdjieff among others. So what's wrong with focusing on that direction? It's certainly how our day-to-day pressures present themselves. It's OK sometimes, but when? That's where a careful diagnosis of a situation merits as much attention as the process design itself.

So where might one begin? At a fundamental level, Heifetz's Leadership Without Easy Answers offers a starting point. In describing when to use technical versus adaptive practices, he suggests we consider the extent to which the challenge is well-defined and the likely solution already known. Similarly, Carlson and Bailey describe the use of the processing mode of thinking for when the variables are known, but the application of the flow mode for when they aren't. A diagnostic tool that allowed a designer to chart a client's situation among such markers would be invaluable.

Additional resources can be found in the literature on various approaches. For instance, on the AI Commons can be found advice on when NOT to use AI: predictable, linear process and outcomes are required; problem-identification/problem-solving is the preferred method for change; there is lack of support for passionate dreaming and inspired self-initiative.

The Creative Problem Solving Process may be a place to start with the development of such a diagnostic tool. In what ways might we use that process to design process?